No web search, no citation? Three measured nuances
By Johnny Lagneau · Updated October 29, 2026Originally published October 29, 2026
Translated from French. Read the original
In short
- Without web search, citations collapse: a Luxembourg broker goes from 40% to 12% of the answers in French.
- 12% is not zero: the models still name a local business from what they have learned.
- The page that gets a business cited is not always the brand's own: this broker comes up in German and in English thanks to its Editus listing.
- Each engine reads its own sources: in Brussels, Perplexity and Grok cite Golden Pages, ChatGPT never does.
On 25 October, Shaun Anderson (Hobo Web) published a formula: if a page is not in the pool of results the engine retrieves, nor in what it keeps after sorting, its probability of being cited by the AI is zero. So GEO is not a practice separate from SEO. I measure this from the other side, on local brands in Belgium and in Luxembourg: 8 buyer questions, 7 AIs, three languages. My figures largely prove him right. With three nuances.
| Language | With web search | Without web search |
|---|---|---|
| French | 40% (20 of 50) | 12% (6 of 50) |
| German | 15% (8 of 53) | 0% (0 of 52) |
| English | 14% (7 of 50) | 4% (2 of 48) |
VectorGap measurements; figures taken from the text of the article, no new figure.
First, what proves him right
Turn off web search: citations collapse. For an insurance broker in Luxembourg, the AIs name it in 40% of the answers in French with web search (20 of 50) and in 12% without (6 of 50). What the AI does not retrieve, it almost never cites.
Nuance 1: 12% is not zero
With no search at all, from what they have learned, the models still name this broker in 12% of the answers. It is not much. It is not zero. A local business exists a little in the memory of the models. That share can be worked on too: what others have published about the business, over the years.
Nuance 2: the page that gets through the door is not always the brand's
This broker has a website in French only. Yet it comes up in the answers in German (15%, 8 of 53) and in English (14%, 7 of 50). The source the AIs cite for it in these two languages is its listing on Editus, the Luxembourg directory, which exists in all three languages. Retrieval governs, yes. But the retrieval of any document that names you, not only of your website.
Nuance 3: there is not one pool, there is one per engine
In Brussels, on the same questions in English, Perplexity and Grok cite Golden Pages (10 answers of 47 with a source). ChatGPT never cited it. A Google ranking is the entry ticket for one engine. Each engine sells its own ticket. None of them reads the same directories.
What I take from it
The formula is true per engine and per retrieved document. That is a narrower claim than “GEO is SEO”. For a local business, it translates into three actions: one page per service and per language on its website, an up-to-date listing in the directory that each engine reads in each language, a measurement engine by engine. A good result on one says nothing about the other.
The Luxembourg figures are on the Luxembourg page, those on directories on the page on directories by language. The method is in how I measure.
